Sunday, January 01, 2012

Buddhism + Modern Construction + Wealth = ?

This is a monastery in central Taiwan that looks to have been funded by some wealthy businessman.  The scale can't really be seen from the photos, but it is huge and most likely had a price tag in the hundreds of millions of US dollars.  There is one room after another of giant images.  Compared to the older temples, this lacks much of the garishness and is simpler, although far larger in terms of scale.  The entire outside is faced with polished marble to make it more impressive.  Much of the structure is for large numbers of hotel like rooms that are for the monks who live there.  Traditional Christian monasteries provided for the livelihood of the monks by working the adjacent land.  This clearly wasn't being done at this monastery, which leaves one wondering what the source of their income is.

Tourists come in and look at the images one-by-one before moving on.  Many take pictures like I did.  A few will offer up a prayer and throw in some money.  Comparing to European tourism of cathedrals, there is some of the same sense as tourists would look at images of the apostles or other Bible scenes.  What is different is the lack of a hall for congregational worship, and the occasional pipe organ concert.

The reason for this post relates to the atheists.  I have heard atheists claim on multiple occasions that Buddhism is much more compatible to atheism than Christianity.  The pretext is that Buddhism is more philosophical and less superstitious than Christianity!  This temple is the simplest of the ones I have seen.  More common was one I saw in the city center where a large number of people were lined up to get their fortune told.








11 comments:

Delirious said...

Less superstitious than Christianity??? Wow...which buddheism where they studying about? Certainly not the one I saw in Asia. :P

Vid said...

I don't know about superstitious, but Buddhism is closer to Atheism in that it has no god.

Dee Ice Hole said...

I loved your pictures as always---hope you had an extremely great trip.

Inklings said...

Beautiful pictures, as usual.

Looney said...

@Delirious, Bunc was one who had made that statement. Too bad he has dropped out of blogging for awhile.

Looney said...

@Vid, I can agree that Buddhism doesn't have a Christian notion of god. What Buddhism does have is a very large number of lesser deities. In their view, these deities are controlling everything directly and behaving in ways that are essentially random and make no cosmic sense. The supernatural is also thoroughly blended with the natural in their theology, thus, they scatter shrines all over the countryside so that people can placate these deities. My favorite is the use of fake paper money. Many of the Buddhist shrines have fireplaces where fake paper money can be burned as a sacrifice to propitiate the spiritual beings.

But as has been said, Buddhism lacks a creator god who brings everything in the physical and spiritual universe under one authority.

Looney said...

@Dee Ice Hole & Inklings.

Thanks again. I feel bad about the travel often since it is a form of conspicuous consumption. But then again, putting this family together from multiple countries is going to be expensive. Hopefully I can share a bit of the experience!

Delirious said...

Ahhh Bunc....gotta love him :)

Max Coutinho said...

Looney,

Atheists know nothing about Buddhism although they pretend to. I always laugh whenever I hear people saying that they want to be buddhists because it doesn't imply the discipline or rigidity of Christianity...how wrong they are *nodding*.

The photos are magnificent: gorgeous images.

I wanted to respond to Vid, but I am giving him time to study Buddhism a bit (which I hope he will).
Buddhism doesn't believe in a god that intervenes, but it does believe in a Creative Force (which, really, is basically the same as our Creative God, only we acknowledge that God is Omnipotent instead of scattering His Power through ever deity on earth [which could also be compared to the powers of God's Angels]).

Complex issue, eh?

Cheers

Looney said...

Max, I suggest Vid should learn Buddhism the way the Chinese do, rather than from the Western academics. That means watching Journey to the West, which is the story of how the Buddhist scriptures got to China. It looks like the videos are up on the net with English subtitles. Here are the first two, but there should be many more. ;-)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTI8OWr1n8M

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhOEfdq4coo&feature=watch_response

Max Coutinho said...

Looney,

I agree with you.
I loved A Journey to the West! It sends a lot of messages and the second video made me thirsty for more...
Vid should definitely watch it.

Remember your telling me that you hadn't found Eurico (by Alexandre Herculano) in another version besides Portuguese? I nearly gave up, but it seems like I may have found something (please check the link below out):

http://www.onread.com/book/Eurico-el-presb-tero-680785/

I will continue to look it up and try to find a version in English.